Back to blogUpdated · 3 min read

Does a petrol or diesel car suit you better?

Our2Cents

Find out if a diesel or petrol car is your best match. Compare costs, performance, and impact to decide what's right for your drive.

Choosing between diesel and petrol cars can feel like navigating a complex maze. With both options offering unique benefits and drawbacks, South African motorists need to weigh their preferences, needs, and the long-term implications of their choice.

Let’s talk about the initial purchase price

Diesel cars usually ask for a bit more cash upfront. Why? Well, they're packed with tech designed to stretch out that fuel efficiency, making them a bit pricier from the get-go. Also, due to the higher initial purchase price, the cost of financing and insurance is also more expensive, at least initially.

What about maintenance costs?

Petrol cars tend to be a bit more low-maintenance, keeping those service bills friendlier to your wallet. Diesel cars, with their sophisticated systems, might see you and your mechanic on a first-name basis, potentially nudging up those maintenance costs.

Which has better performance and driving experience?

The performance and what the car feels like when you drive it are also critical factors. Diesel cars have this cool ability to give you a lot of power at low speeds, which is awesome for pulling heavy stuff or when you're fully loaded and hitting the road for a long trip. They're pretty good on fuel on the highways too. Petrol cars, though, they're the fun ones. They rev higher and get moving quickly, making them a blast for city driving or when you want to speed up fast. They're smooth and responsive, perfect for those who love a lively drive.

If you're all about saving on fuel and need that strength for heavy lifting, diesel's your friend. But if you're looking for that zip and excitement, petrol's where it's at. Your choice really comes down to how and where you drive, and what you enjoy most about being behind the wheel.

Let’s look at the impact on our planet

Diesel cars are a bit of a mixed bag. On one hand, they're champs at keeping CO2 emissions lower per mile, which is good news for the big picture of global warming. But, they're not so great because they emit more NOx and particulates. These nasties can mess with air quality and aren't too friendly to our health.

At the same time, petrol cars play a different game. They tend to pump out more CO2, so they're contributing a bit more to global warming. But, they're cleaner when it comes to those immediate pollutants like NOx and particulates, making them a bit kinder to our lungs and the air we breathe.

How far will they take you on a tank of petrol?

If you're looking to get more bang for your buck at the fuel pump, diesel cars usually win. They can take you further on a tank, especially if you're hitting the highways, which is a plus for both your wallet and CO2 emissions over the long haul.

Petrol cars might not stretch the fuel as far, but they're not trailing too far behind. They're typically more about giving you a smooth and peppy drive, especially in the city or if you like a bit of zip in your ride.

In the end, choosing between diesel and petrol comes down to what matters more to you. If you're all about efficiency and longer drives with fewer stops for fuel (and don't mind the environmental trade-offs), diesel could be your go-to. But, if you prefer a cleaner option for city driving and are okay with a bit more CO2 for a smoother ride, then petrol might just be your match.

Comparison table between petrol cars and diesel cars, highlighting key features: fuel efficiency, cost of fuel, engine noise, maintenance cost, engine longevity, emissions, initial cost, driving experience, and insurance. Petrol cars generally have lower fuel efficiency, quieter engines, lower maintenance costs, shorter engine lifespan, more CO2 emissions, cheaper initial cost, smoother acceleration, and potentially lower insurance. Diesel cars offer higher fuel efficiency, louder engines, higher maintenance costs, longer engine lifespan, less CO2 but more NOx emissions, higher initial cost, stronger acceleration, and possibly higher insurance costs.

So, what suits you best?

The decision often boils down to personal driving habits, with those covering long distances leaning towards diesel for its efficiency, while city drivers prefer petrol for its convenience and performance.

Consider how the differences in cost, performance, and environmental impact align with your lifestyle. Whether it's the efficiency and torque of diesel for long commutes and heavy loads or the smoothness and agility of petrol for city driving, the choice is deeply personal.

So, what should you buy? If you're doing a lot of long-distance driving and are looking for fuel efficiency, a diesel car might still make sense for you. But keep in mind, that the resale value might be affected as the market shifts towards EVs. For city driving and short trips, petrol cars are a reliable and cost-effective option. They offer a smooth driving experience and are generally cheaper to buy than diesel or electric cars.

Petrol or diesel, fast lanes or fuel efficiency, the road's yours to take. But hey, let's not forget one thing – keeping that car of yours covered is key. With Naked, getting comprehensive car insurance is a breeze. No endless calls, no mountains of paperwork. Just pure, simple cover in 90 seconds. Ready to roll? Let's get you covered.

SHARE

You might also like

Our2Cents

How to change ownership of a car

Get the scoop on changing ownership of a car in South Africa with our easy guide. Find out what documents you need and how to handle the process smoothly.

3 min read
Our2Cents

12 must-read books this December

Team Naked’s favourite reads.

10 min read
Our2Cents

10 things I wish I’d known before moving into my own place

Nothing says adulting quite like moving into your own place. So a few of us at Naked have shared some things we wish we had known when we first made the big leap.

4 min read